Fun

Proof-of-Reserves Are at ‘Best Incomplete, at Worst Misleading and Deceptive’ Says Crypto Analyst Martin Hiesboeck

News Feed - 2022-12-02 01:12:05

Proof-of-Reserves Are at "Best Incomplete, at Worst Misleading and Deceptive" Says Crypto Analyst Martin Hiesboeck


While many crypto exchanges have seemingly embraced the use of proof-of-reserves (PoR) to showcase their transparency and reassure nervous users, crypto analyst Martin Hiesboeck insists such so-called proofs are susceptible to manipulation or misrepresentation. He added that PoRs alone are not a suitable method of verifying an exchange’s reserves because they do not “account for liabilities and off-chain assets at all.” PoR May Be ‘Misleading and Deceptive’


Following the collapse of FTX in November, trust in centralized exchanges ebbed, with many users rushing to move their assets off of such platforms. This, in turn, sparked a rush by crypto exchanges to present or publish their proof-of-reserves (PoR).


Seen as an emergency response to the confidence crisis created by FTX’s fall, PoR Merkle trees have seemingly become the de-facto standard measure used to project a crypto exchange’s transparency. Proponents of PoR assert that using this audit method reassures users that a crypto exchange is not misusing their funds.


However, despite their apparent embrace by many in the crypto industry, presenting PoR audits alone may not prove that an exchange is not misusing client funds. It is also alleged that some crypto exchanges are lending each other funds just prior to an audit and returning these immediately after a PoR has been presented.


To critics like Martin Hiesboeck, a crypto analyst and head of blockchain and crypto research at the multi-asset digital trading platform Uphold, PoRs are not suitable tools for proving the status of an exchange’s reserves because they do not “account for liabilities and off-chain assets at all.” This according to Hiesboeck makes PoRs “at best incomplete, at worst misleading and deceptive.”


Commenting on why some in the crypto space have seemingly endorsed PoRs, Hiesboeck told Bitcoin.com News:


“The Merkle Tree PoR has seen increased adoption and interest in the past few weeks due to shaken trust in centralized exchanges. CEXs [centralized exchanges] needed a fast and public ’emergency response’ to restore public and user trust, and this is why the so-called Proof of Reserves method became so popular and is currently touted as the best way to prove an exchange’s transparency — at least on paper.”




Nevertheless, Hiesboeck notes that PoRs have two issues that make them susceptible to manipulation or misrepresentation. One is what Hiesboeck describes as the inherent opaqueness of a Merkle Tree model. This model by design “allows for the verification of certain data without divulging its contents.”


For centralized exchanges using this model, it means their respective auditors can publish a “legitimate snapshot” of a crypto exchange platform’s reserves. Explaining why he finds this problematic, Hiesboeck said: Regular onlookers have no means to verify the results of PoRs nor assurance that funds weren’t moved from these addresses immediately after the audit. To solve this issue, at least partially, there needs to be some kind of a real-time independent reserve monitoring system to provide up-to-date information over time.


The exclusion of an exchange’s outstanding liabilities in PoRs is another issue making them a less reliable way of verifying or ascertaining a crypto exchange platform’s financial well-being. Therefore presenting or publishing a crypto exchange’s assets without also revealing its liabilities does not provide an accurate picture of the platform’s financial health, Hiesboeck argued.


“Many exchanges that have published PoRs don’t include such information, meaning they are non-transparent. Nor do they reflect any custodians’ off-chain assets and where these funds originated from,” he added.


Still, despite Hiesboeck and other critics’ arguments against the use of this model, PoRs appear to have gained traction. Asreported by Bitcoin.com News, several large crypto exchanges have presented audits based on the Merkle tree model. Binance, one of the world’s largest crypto exchange platforms, recently published its PoR for bitcoin. The snapshot suggested that Binance’s BTC reserves were slightly more than net user balances.


Meanwhile, when asked if there is a better alternative verification method, Hiesboeck replied:


“The only alternative to a Merkle Tree PoR is a system that provides a combination of reserves and liabilities. It should include proof that the operating entities are domiciled in the right jurisdictions and that any attestation has been subject to review by an external auditing firm.” Tags in this story Binance, Blockchain, Centralized Exchange, CEX, crypto exchange, FTX collapse, Martin Hiesboeck, Merkle tree, off-chain assets, Proof of Reserves


What are your thoughts on this story? Let us know what you think in the comments section below. Terence Zimwara


Terence Zimwara is a Zimbabwe award-winning journalist, author and writer. He has written extensively about the economic troubles of some African countries as well as how digital currencies can provide Africans with an escape route. Blockchain Pilgrimage: Regulating Crypto "Should Be Combined With Education" Says Top Wadzpay Executive INTERVIEW | 3 days ago "Cryptocurrencies Like Bitcoin Make Global Commerce Easy" — Founder of Nigerian Crypto Exchange INTERVIEW | 6 days ago


Image Credits: Shutterstock, Pixabay, Wiki Commons, Dr. Martin Hiesboeck, Twitter Previous article‘Big Short’ Investor Michael Burry Warns of Extended Multi-Year Recession in US Next articleWeb3 Antivirus Is Now on Guard of Your Digital Assets Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. It is not a direct offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or a recommendation or endorsement of any products, services, or companies. Bitcoin.com does not provide investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice. Neither the company nor the author is responsible, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any content, goods or services mentioned in this article. Read disclaimerShow comments More Popular NewsIn Case You Missed ItRipple CEO: SEC Lawsuit Over XRP "Has Gone Exceedingly Well"


The CEO of Ripple Labs says that the lawsuit brought by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) against him and his company over XRP "has gone exceedingly well." He stressed: "This case is important, not just for Ripple, it’s ... read more.Oman to Incorporate Real Estate Tokenization in Virtual Assets Regulatory Framework NFT Sales Volume Saw a Small Uptick This Week — Moonbirds, Mutant Apes Take Top Sales Privacy-Centric Monero Plans for July Hard Fork, Plans Include Ring Signature, Bulletproof Upgrade Ethereum Foundation"s Financial Report Discloses It Holds $1.6 Billion in Assets, 80.5% Held in Ether

News Feed

Bitcoin.com Exchange To List HUB Token as the Next Gen Trust-Based Cryptocurrency
Bitcoin.com Exchange To List HUB Token as the Next Gen Trust-Based Cryptocurrency PRESS RELEASE. Bitcoin.com Exchange is thrilled to announce the upcoming listin
Crypto Asset Trading Platform Bityard With Integrated Copy Trading Function Launched in USA
Crypto Asset Trading Platform Bityard With Integrated Copy Trading Function Launched in USA PRESS RELEASE. Bityard, a fairly new crypto exchange, currently focus
Gamestop Launches Web3 Ethereum Wallet That Leverages Loopring’s ZK-Rollup Tech
Gamestop Launches Web3 Ethereum Wallet That Leverages Loopring’s ZK-Rollup Tech This week, the consumer electronics and gaming software retailer, Gamestop, has officially reveale
Binance Joins Governance Council of Kakao’s Klaytn Blockchain
Binance has joined the governance council of Kakao’s Klaytn blockchain network as the project scrambles for partners and “use cases” and seeks to building its legitimacy.
Bitcoin Revolution South Africa: Scam Claims Support by President Cyril Ramaphosa
Bitcoin Revolution South Africa: Scam Claims Support by President Cyril RamaphosaA bitcoin investment scheme called “Bitcoin Revolution South Africa” has been gaining mu
The $100K Mirage: Bitcoin’s Rally Not Backed By On-Chain Strength
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu
Tether Defends Its Record, Blasts WSJ For ‘Irresponsible Reporting’
Este artículo también está disponible en español. In a recent report by the Wall Street Journal (WSJ), it was alleged that Tether is currently under federal investigation
Bitcoin Surges Past $93,000 – Can A Breakthrough Unlock New Heights?
Este artículo también está disponible en español. Bitcoinis on the move again, surging toward its previous high of $93,257 with renewed momentum that has triggered excite
XRP Price Prediction To $4.9: How The 1-Day 50 MA Will Drive The Next Wave
Este artículo también está disponible en español. A crypto analyst has issued a new XRP price prediction, forecasting a potential breakout that could see the prominent cr
Ana Paula Pereira5 hours agodYdX founder claims targeted attack led to $9M insurance claimdYdX founder Antonio Juliano said that the decentralized exchange as well as the Yearn.Finance token (YFI) are victims of a target
Ethereum at 9: Industry leaders reflect on the ecosystem
Savannah Fortis9 hours agoEthereum at 9: Industry leaders reflect on the ecosystemAs Ethereum celebrates its ninth anniversary, we reflect on its transformative journey and share nine key insights from leading executives
$WEPE Hits $40M as Meme Coin Market Recovers
The most trending meme coin and one of the fastest-growing tokens right now, Wall Street Pepe ($WEPE), has crossed the $40 million mark during its ongoing presale. $WEPE raised $100