Fun

Kleiman Estate Asks Judge to Overrule Craig Wright’s Objections

News Feed - 2019-12-18 01:12:22

Kleiman Estate Asks Judge to Overrule Craig Wright"s Objections


On December 16, new court filings from the Kleiman v. Wright case show the plaintiffs have responded to Wright’s objections against the magistrate’s court order. Kleiman’s lawyer Velvel Freedman explained that Craig’s statements in court “lacked credibility,” his constant change of stories “demonstrates falsity” and Freedman claims Wright’s “trust documents are forgeries.”


Also read: Plustoken Cash-Outs Could Be Behind BTC Price Drop, Says Report Wright’s Conduct Antithetical to the Administration of Justice, Says Kleiman Attorney


Since Valentine’s Day 2018, the self-proclaimed Bitcoin inventor Craig Wright has been defending himself in court against the Kleiman family. The lawsuit started because the Kleiman estate believes Wright manipulated the now deceased David Kleiman’s bitcoin assets and intellectual property. The lawsuit has been one of the most high profile cases in the U.S. because it involves billions of dollars in BTC that was ostensibly stored in a blind trust.



After months of discovery hearings, objections, and court orders, the Kleiman estate filed a new motion against Wright’s objection towards Judge Reinhart’s recent court order. On August 26, Wright was ordered by Southern District Court of Florida to distribute half of his bitcoin holdings and intellectual property assets from prior to 2014. At first, Wright and his legal team came to a non-binding settlement, but the deal eventually fell through. After the settlement was broken, Wright attempted to object to Judge Reinhart’s order, claiming a lack of jurisdiction. In the filing on submitted on Tuesday, Velvel Freedman noted that Wright believes he’s been treated unfairly, but Freedman stressed that Wright’s issues in court stem from “his own conduct.”



“Craig is not the victim here. On the contrary, as Judge Reinhart found, Craig’s conduct in this litigation has been ‘antithetical to the administration of justice’ and ‘no lesser sanction would suffice,’” Freedman wrote. Freedman asserted that the record supports Judge Reinhart’s findings and remedy entirely while the order is “absolutely justified given the gravity of Craig’s offenses.” Kleiman’s lawyer added: Indeed, Craig’s Objection to the order, far from calling into question its correctness, demonstrates that he is recalcitrant, and – given the opportunity – would engage in the same conduct that led to the order in the first place. In fact, mere hours after Judge Reinhart read the order into the record, Craig walked out of court and into an interview where he admitted that he lied to the court. The next day he gave an interview calling Judge Reinhart a ‘silly judge.’ Kleiman’s lawyer Velvel Freedman noted that after the court order, Wright did an interview with Modern Consensus columnist Brendan Sullivan. Exhibit 3 filed on December 16, 2019. A Fanciful and Self-Conflicting Story


Freedman then said that the plaintiffs attempted to use the discovery process to identify the bitcoin mined as part of the partnership between Wright and Kleiman. Wright, of course, objected and the objection was subsequently overruled by Judge Reinhart. On June 11, 2019, Craig told the court for the first time that providing plaintiffs with a list of his bitcoin holdings was “impossible” because he did not possess the information necessary to access it. Reinhart then gave Wright the opportunity to explain why he couldn’t access the funds. “To carry that burden, Craig told (under oath) a fanciful story about a mysterious ‘encrypted file’ held in a trust — Not only did this story conflict with his previous sworn testimony and his motion papers, as explained below, the story itself was self-conflicting,” the plaintiffs’ filing revealed. “In support of his story, Craig put forward documents which he swore were ‘authentic’ to prove that the ‘encrypted file’ and the trust exist. Plaintiffs exposed these documents as forgeries.” Freedman’s filing continued: Instead of being ashamed, or trying to hide behind some procedural or legal technicality, Craig brazenly opened his objection to Judge Reinhart’s order by asserting that ‘there is absolutely no basis for imposing any sanctions’ on him because ‘the uncontroverted evidence shows that he is unable to access a listing of’ his bitcoin. The only thing ‘uncontroverted’ about Craig is that he’s a perjurer and a forger. Craig’s claim that his ‘testimony stands unrebutted by plaintiffs’ is simply blind to reality. Excerpt from Exhibit 3 filed on December 16, 2019.


The motion against Wright’s recent objection highlights the time when Wright was confronted with evidence indicating that certain documents had been fabricated or altered and he “became extremely defensive.” Wright tried to “sidestep questioning” and made “vague comments about his systems being hacked and others having access to his computers.” None of these excuses have been corroborated by other evidence, Freedman’s filing insisted. Moreover, the Kleiman attorney also noted that Wright vehemently claimed “there are no public addresses in the Bitcoin system” and further stated that “public addresses don’t exist.” Freedman says that this absurdity is akin to saying: How do unicorns relate to this Court? The Plaintiffs Assert That Wright’s Objections Should Be Overruled in Their Entirety


Following 29 pages of arguments, Freedman concluded that the court is faced with a man who “has no respect for the authority of the court, or for the fair administration of justice.” The plaintiffs wholeheartedly believe Wright has lied throughout the entire lawsuit and is now attempting to hide behind a “blanket of due process.” Freedman concluded by underlining that Judge Reinhart gave Wright the opportunity to show that his admitted violation of the court’s order was due to the impossibility of compliance.


“Craig was sanctioned harshly, but fairly — Craig’s objections should be overruled in their entirety,” Freedman added. According to the court docket, a discovery hearing conference will be held on December 18 in West Palm Beach court. Lawsuit participants are allowed to attend the discovery via telephone by using the court’s conference call system.


What do you think about Kleiman’s latest filing against Wright’s objection? Let us know what you think about this subject in the comments section below.


Image credits: Shutterstock, Bitcoin.com, Twitter, Wiki Commons, Fair Use, and Pixabay.


Did you know you can verify any unconfirmed Bitcoin transaction with our Bitcoin Block Explorer tool? Simply complete a Bitcoin address search to view it on the blockchain. Plus, visit our Bitcoin Charts to see what’s happening in the industry. Share this story: Tags in this story 1.1 Million BTC, billions, Bitcoin, Bonded Courier, BTC, Craig Wright, David Kleiman, Encrypted Files, Forgeries, Ira Kleiman, Judge Reinhart, Kleiman Estate, Lawsuit, lies, manipulation, Southern District Court of Florida, Tulip Trust, Velvel Freedman Related Fidelity Launching Crypto Services in Europe, Citing "Significant Interest" NEWS | Kevin Helms


Fidelity Investments is expanding its crypto services to European clients after seeing increasing potential in this market. The expansion builds… read more. Plustoken Cash-Outs Could Be Behind BTC Price Drop, Says Report NEWS | Jamie Redman


On Monday, the blockchain surveillance company Chainalysis published an excerpt from the firm’s upcoming crime report that will publish in… read more. Jamie Redman


Jamie Redman is a financial tech journalist living in Florida. Redman has been an active member of the cryptocurrency community since 2011. He has a passion for Bitcoin, open source code, and decentralized applications. Redman has written thousands of articles for news.Bitcoin.com about the disruptive protocols emerging today. Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.

News Feed

Bitcoin’s Weekly Chart May See Golden Cross for First Time in 3.5 Years
View Bitcoin’s short-term 50-period moving average is edging closer toward the longer-term 100-period moving average on the weekly chart, hinting at a potential bullish “golden cross” formation for the firs
Turner Wright4 hours agoJudge revokes Sam Bankman-Fried’s bail, remands him to custody: ReportSam Bankman-Fried was reportedly led out of a New York courtroom in handcuffs after alleged attempts to influence or intimid
Israeli Police Arrest Beitar Jerusalem Owner and 7 Suspects in Multimillion-Dollar Crypto Fraud
Israeli Police Arrest Beitar Jerusalem Owner and 7 Suspects in Multimillion-Dollar Crypto Fraud Israeli police have arrested eight suspects in connection with a cryptocurrency frau
Marcel Pechman39 minutes agoBitcoin blasts past its 2021 all-time high in Argentina, but hyperinflation outpaces gainsBitcoin’s 150% gains over the last two years in Argentine pesos is no match for the country’s 300%
Canada lacks engagement from lawmakers on crypto — Coinbase exec
Turner Wright3 hours agoCanada lacks engagement from lawmakers on crypto — Coinbase execThe Canada country director for Coinbase said local regulators were “much more collaborative” with the industry than their U.S
Bitget Shares Merkle Tree Proof of Reserves to Enhance Transparency Users’ Assets Safeguarded With at Least 1:1 Reserve Ratio
Bitget Shares Merkle Tree Proof of Reserves to Enhance Transparency Users" Assets Safeguarded With at Least 1:1 Reserve Ratio sponsored Leading global cryptocurrency exchange, Bitge
Anchor Protocol’s Earn Rate Adjusts for the First Time, From 19.4 to 18% APY
Anchor Protocol"s Earn Rate Adjusts for the First Time, From 19.4 to 18% APY Following the governance vote that aimed to implement a semi-dynamic earn rate for the Anchor Protocol,
US Lawmaker Urges SEC to Go After Major Crypto Exchanges That Traded XRP
US Lawmaker Urges SEC to Go After Major Crypto Exchanges That Traded XRP U.S. Congressman Brad Sherman has urged the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to go after major
US Fintech Firm Acorns Adds Crypto Exposure Investing via Proshares Bitcoin ETF
US Fintech Firm Acorns Adds Crypto Exposure Investing via Proshares Bitcoin ETF The American financial technology (fintech) firm Acorns has announced customers now have the option
Report: Chinese Customs Authority Confiscates 49 Old ASIC Antminers
Report: Chinese Customs Authority Confiscates 49 Old ASIC Antminers Chinese authorities continue to crackdown against bitcoin miners after they seized 49 second-hand Bitmain ASIC A
FBI Renews Warning About Pig Butchering Crypto Scam Sweeping the Country
FBI Renews Warning About Pig Butchering Crypto Scam Sweeping the Country The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has reiterated its warning about a very popular crypto investment
Biggest Movers: ADA Hits 1-Week High, HNT Nearly 20% Higher on Monday
Biggest Movers: ADA Hits 1-Week High, HNT Nearly 20% Higher on Monday Cardano was nearly 15% higher on Monday, as crypto markets were mainly in the green to start the week. Despite