Fun

UK FCA approves crypto investment products, but there’s a catch

News Feed - 2024-03-15 08:03:50

Robert D. Knight12 hours agoUK FCA approves crypto investment products, but there’s a catchThe U.K.’s Financial Conduct Authority says it won’t object to the creation of crypto-backed exchange-traded notes — a financial product similar to an ETF — on the condition they are restricted to professional investors only.6344 Total views2 Total sharesListen to article 0:00Follow upOwn this piece of crypto historyCollect this article as NFTJoin us on social networksCrypto industry figures have welcomed news that the United Kingdom’s main financial watchdog will make it easier to list crypto investment products.


On March 11, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) announced that it would allow professional investors to trade crypto exchange-traded notes (ETNs) created by recognized investment exchanges (RIEs).


Even so, restrictions that prohibit the participation of retail investors remain, making the FCA’s announcement a partial victory only for broader crypto adoption.


Regulatory conditions in Europe prohibit the offering of an exchange-traded fund (ETF) for a single asset, such as Bitcoin (BTC) or Ether (ETH). This makes ETNs the favored exchange-traded product (ETP) in the European Union and the U.K., where financial rules are still broadly harmonized despite Brexit.


With the green light from the FCA, British traditional finance and U.K. traders may shortly have easier access to crypto-tied financial products. Since the go-ahead also comes with conditions, it is perhaps unsurprising that the caveats become the focus.


Natalia Latka, policy director at blockchain analytics firm Merkle Science, told Cointelegraph, “The FCA’s decision to allow recognized investment exchanges to list crypto [ETNs] is a significant move forward. Despite the restrictions, this action not only fosters the integration of cryptocurrency-related products into a regulated environment but also narrows the divide between the crypto sector and the traditional financial industry.”


Latka also noted the exclusion of retail investors.


“Despite aspirations to become a crypto hub, the U.K.’s approach underscores a notable hesitancy to embrace the rapidly growing interest in crypto assets among retail investors,” said Latka.


Cointelegraph spoke with George McDonaugh, co-founder and co-managing director of KR1, a European digital asset investment company. McDonaugh lauded the move but said the market needs to be more accessible.


“The news that the FCA will not object to requests from [RIEs] to create a U.K. listed market segment for crypto asset-backed [ETNs] is a move in the right direction for the U.K. regulatory environment for crypto,” McDonaugh said.


McDonaugh also focused on inclusion, stating that more companies need to be enfranchised into U.K. markets.


Recent: Moon or doom: Why do so many crypto startups fail?


He said, “We would like more to be done around the U.K.’s listing regime, allowing more companies to join the Main Market of the London Stock Exchange and its junior market, for the U.K. government, other policymakers and the industry to achieve its ambition of becoming a truly global hub for the crypto industry.”


Whatever way you slice it, the conclusion is broadly similar; if the U.K. is serious about its nebulous crypto hub aspirations, it needs to do more to broaden participation fast.The crypto hub dream


It’s been some time since U.K. Prime Minister Rishi Sunak announced his plan to prioritize financial technology in Britain. In July 2021, as Chancellor of the Exchequer, Sunak promised to “implement a sweeping set of financial services reforms” over the next few years.


InApril 2022, Sunak said, “It’s my ambition to make the U.K. a global hub for crypto asset technology.”We"re working to make the UK a global cryptoassets hub. We want to see the businesses of tomorrow, and the jobs they create, here in the UK.

Today @JohnGlenUK set out how we are going to encourage crypto investment and technology in UK markets. https://t.co/MdZ5IOLZtH— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) April 4, 2022


Despite these ambitions, the FCA remains incredibly cautious about the industry, and measurable advancement is hard to come by. Under these conditions, even a small positive step in the right direction feels like cause for celebration.


In a statement sent to Cointelegraph, a spokesperson for CryptoUK, the U.K.-based trade association for crypto, said, “We advocated for this type of change, in line with our support for proportionate and measured regulation that is consistent and provides a level playing field for all types of innovation.”


“With that in mind, we will continue to advocate for a reconsideration of the existing bans on access to appropriate financial investments for retail investors,” said the spokesperson. “Whilst we fully support a robust suite of investor protections, we want to highlight concerns around whether these bans are proportionate and in line with policy for similar investments that do not involve crypto assets.”


With the U.K.’s goal of becoming a crypto asset hub, it makes sense the FCA might want to make it a special case for the industry, but only if the starting assumptions were broadly to its benefit. Instead, the opposite is true.A longstanding stance


The FCA established its ultra-cautious position toward crypto on Oct. 6, 2020. The body laid out the five reasons for its decision:The inherent nature of the underlying assets, i.e., they have no reliable basis for valuation.Prevalence of market abuse and financial crime in the secondary market (e.g., cyber theft).Extreme volatility in crypto asset price movements.Inadequate understanding of crypto assets by retail consumers.Lack of legitimate investment need for retail consumers to invest in these products.


According to CoinMarketCap, on Oct. 6, 2020 — the day FCA excluded retail investors from the sale of crypto-derivatives such as ETNs — the price of Bitcoin was around $10,000. Ether was valued at around $350. At the time of writing, the price of Bitcoin was $67,139, while Ether’s was $3,648.


Given the upward-price trajectory for BTC and ETH over the period, Cointelegraph asked the FCA if it might be willing to reconsider its ETN ban for retail investors. 


A spokesperson for the FCA said, “The FCA’s ban on offering cETNs [small c for crypto] or crypto derivatives to retail consumers remains in place as we continue to see significant harms in the crypto market.”


As to whether that might change in the near future, they added, “The FCA has previously communicated that it would continue to keep its position on cETNs under review.”


Naturally, industry insiders hope that the “under review” status brings some meaningful change as swiftly as possible.Inconsistency and bans


In the United States, spot Bitcoin ETFs were approved only after significant industry, legal and political pressure. By comparison, the path to a U.K. ETN appears relatively painless, even if work is yet to be done to ensure greater accessibility.


As Latka points out, “Gary Gensler, the SEC [U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission] chair, emphasized that such [ETF] approval should not be misconstrued as an official endorsement of Bitcoin. This distinction is crucial. It’s plausible that the FCA in the U.K. is influenced by a concern that allowing certain crypto-referenced products could unintentionally signal that the underlying crypto assets themselves are regulated, despite their actual unregulated status.”


Recent: Elizabeth Warren crypto bill draws criticism and sparks election challenge


But even if the FCA is motivated by the best intentions, Latka believes its stance could ultimately prove damaging to the people it is intended to protect.


Latka says, “The FCA’s ban might drive investors toward the shadows of unregulated exchanges, increasing their vulnerability [...] I believe that the path to safeguarding these investors should lie not in outright prohibitions but in adopting comprehensive regulations that allow safe exposure to this asset class.”


As CryptoUK put it, there is still a “need for further public-private sector collaboration with domestic and global policymakers.”


From an industry insider’s perspective, FCA policy remains a work in progress.# Bitcoin# Bitcoin Price# Investments# ETF# Bitcoin Regulation# UK Government# United Kingdom# Cryptocurrency Investment# RegulationAdd reactionAdd reactionRead morePrice analysis 3/15: BTC, ETH, BNB, SOL, XRP, ADA, DOGE, AVAX, SHIB, DOTWealth manager Cetera adds spot BTC ETFs to it platform, with trainingBitcoin overtakes gold in investor portfolio allocation — JPMorgan

News Feed

Solana Stays Strong Despite BTC Drop – $176 Next?
Este artículo también está disponible en español. Solana (SOL) is holding strong above the $160 mark after the broader market experienced a healthy dip to previous demand
President of Bank of Brazil Shows ‘Open Finance’ Digital Real Concept Featuring Stablecoin Integration and Payments Functionality
President of Bank of Brazil Shows "Open Finance" Digital Real Concept Featuring Stablecoin Integration and Payments Functionality Roberto Campos Neto, president of the Bank of Braz
Bitcoin Price Crash Below $100,000 Not The End As Analyst Predicts Another 52% Jump
Este artículo también está disponible en español. The Bitcoin price action in the past 24 hours saw it breaking below the $100,000 price mark again very briefly before br
Independent Russian News Site Meduza Raises Over $200,000 in Crypto
Independent Russian News Site Meduza Raises Over $200,000 in Crypto Pressure from the Kremlin and sanctions from the West have forced Russian news outlet Meduza to increasingly rel
Ghanaian Cedi Second Worst-Performing Asset Among Sub-Saharan Africa’s Top 15 Currencies
Ghanaian Cedi Second Worst-Performing Asset Among Sub-Saharan Africa"s Top 15 Currencies In just the first 17 days of the new year, the Ghanaian currency reportedly depreciated by
Morgan Stanley’s Executive Likens Bitcoin’s Resilience to Kenny Who Dies in Every South Park Episode
Morgan Stanley"s Executive Likens Bitcoin"s Resilience to Kenny Who Dies in Every South Park Episode Morgan Stanley Investment Management’s Dennis Lynch, says that bitcoin&#
Bitcoin back above $65K as traders shake off Mt. Gox BTC transfers
Nancy Lubale5 hours agoBitcoin back above $65K as traders shake off Mt. Gox BTC transfersTraders ignored the news that Mt. Gox transferred billions of dollars in BTC and instead focused on pushing Bitcoin price above $65
Ethereum Classic Climbs 124% in 2 Weeks, Hashrate Spikes, KRW Captures 20% of ETC’s Trade Volume
Ethereum Classic Climbs 124% in 2 Weeks, Hashrate Spikes, KRW Captures 20% of ETC"s Trade Volume Roughly six years ago in July 2016, an Ethereum hard fork was used to address the i
While the New LUNA Records Gains, Do Kwon’s Terraform Labs Is Plagued by Controversy and Accusations
While the New LUNA Records Gains, Do Kwon"s Terraform Labs Is Plagued by Controversy and Accusations It’s been two days since the Terra development team launched the new Pho
UAE’s RAK DAO and Tencent Cloud ink deal to boost crypto startups
Ezra Reguerra10 hours agoUAE’s RAK DAO and Tencent Cloud ink deal to boost crypto startupsThe memorandum of understanding includes the establishment of a Tencent Cloud training center for skill development and educatio
Amazon denies using AI voice in Road House remake
Arijit Sarkar13 hours agoAmazon denies using AI voice in Road House remakeRoad House scriptwriter Lance Hill sued Amazon Studios for alleged misuse of AI and copyright infringement during the movie’s upcoming remake.10
Yashu Gola19 hours agoWorldcoin stuck after 70% drop from peak — More downside for WLD price?WLD price may get anchored to $2 until October, primarily due to its initial supply distribution.3956 Total views15 Total sha