Fun

EU crypto regulations undermined by lack of enforcement, say observers

News Feed - 2024-05-08 12:05:00

Robert D. Knight8 hours agoEU crypto regulations undermined by lack of enforcement, say observersThe European Union’s Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation is being phased in, but regulators have reportedly been inconsistent in enforcing existing laws.862 Total views9 Total sharesListen to article 0:00InterviewOwn this piece of crypto historyCollect this article as NFTJoin us on social networksThe European Union’s flagship crypto legislation, passed in 2023, is coming into effect this year, but pre-existing legislation has not been enforced evenly.


This is according to Jon Helgi Egilsson, chair and founder of Monerium, a licensed e-money issuer operating in the region.


According to Egilsson, the new regulations — the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) — are built upon the EU’s Electronic Money Directive (EMD II), which has been flouted for years.


Egilsson expressed dismay at the general state of enforcement and how it impacts e-money firms in the region.


“If you issue e-money, you have to be licensed as an e-money institution,” Egilsson said. “If you don’t, then you’re subject to fines and jail time.”


This is the situation as Egilsson reads it, but as he explained, not everyone faces the same level of scrutiny.“We are competing with companies both in Europe and outside of Europe, which are doing similar things, but they haven’t received any license.”


While that might be enough to concern e-money issuers, in some ways, becoming licensed only creates additional problems.


Egilsson said, “As a licensed entity, you are restricted, what you can do, how you can promote it, how you can solicit it [...] You have to submit reports, and then the regulator comes back and says, ‘You’re not doing this.’”


Recent: Bitcoin L2s set to explode as Runes congest BTC network


Therefore, becoming a licensed issuer with regulatory oversight involves “a lot of overhead and cost.”


But while Monerium operates under close regulatory scrutiny, other forms of money, including stablecoins, do not.


“I think it’s remarkable that regulators somehow allow this to happen and have been allowing this for years now,” said a clearly unhappy Egilsson.A disparity in enforcement


Cointelegraph spoke with Natalia Latka, policy director and regulatory affairs at blockchain analysis firm Merkle Science, to understand why this disparity in enforcement has emerged.


Latka explained that in the EU “there are two main divergent legal viewpoints” surrounding the regulation of electronic money tokens (EMTs) or stablecoins.


The first school of thought focuses on the predominance of the Electronic Money Directive.


As Latka says, “According to this school, the EMD directly applied to EMTs before MiCA was enacted, making MiCA a regulation that does not introduce completely new rules but rather reinforces and elaborates upon the existing framework established by the EMD.”


Latka said that this view finds support in Article 48(2) of MiCA, “which explicitly states that e-money tokens shall be considered as electronic money, confirming the application of the EMD to EMTs.”


However, an alternative school of thought within the EU appears to have informed regulators’ approach.MiCA is king


The second school of thought believes MiCA is the primary legislation for stablecoins or EMTs.


“Supporters of this school emphasize the significant differences between EMTs and traditional electronic money,” said Latka.


As regulators see it, stablecoins create additional risk factors that are not present in e-money. Self-custodial wallets create one such systematic risk factor.


Another risk factor emerges from global stablecoins that could become systemic. The European Commission considered the EMD’s provisions unsuitable for tackling the inherent risks of such a scenario.


Latka said, “It’s important to note that while the commission could have regulated e-money tokens under the EMD, this option was discussed but ultimately not pursued. Instead, the decision was made to create a bespoke regulatory framework that coexists with the EMD to address all regulatory gaps effectively.”


The issue for industry insiders such as Egilsson is that while this new regulatory framework was discussed, debated, approved and enacted, there has not been parity of enforcement.


Given the issues Egilsson raised, Cointelegraph asked if MiCA would make a difference.


“I sincerely believe they will enforce it,” Egilsson said.An open question


With MiCA coming fully into force later in 2024 and concerned parties such as Egilsson optimistic about its effect, it might appear that the legal debate on stablecoins and e-money is over.


Recent: Where to store your crypto: Wallets provide diverse options for holders


However, MiCA only represents the next step in an ongoing discussion. Far more detail needs to be worked out, which could take years.


“There isn’t a definitive answer to this debate, and it is essential that the EU authorities provide clear guidance,” said Latka. “The industry needs additional clarifications, especially regarding how MiCA interacts with existing EU financial regulations and directives. The interplay of MiCA with other financial laws requires a well-defined demarcation and a strategy for resolving any conflicting or overlapping regulations.”# Law# Europe# Adoption# Digital Currency# European Union# Stablecoin# RegulationAdd reaction

News Feed

Aloha Browser Paves the Way Towards Web3 With Recent HNS Integration
Aloha Browser Paves the Way Towards Web3 With Recent HNS Integration press release PRESS RELEASE.Aloha Browser is paving the way towards a decentralized web with the recent Handshak
XRP Whales Are Back – 880 Million Tokens Accumulated This Month
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu
ESG Analyst Daniel Batten Reveals Dynamic Charts Showing Bitcoin’s 52.6% Sustainable Energy Use
ESG Analyst Daniel Batten Reveals Dynamic Charts Showing Bitcoin’s 52.6% Sustainable Energy Use Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) analyst Daniel Batten said Tuesday tha
Crypto Wealth Manager Vaneck Launches Polygon and Avalanche Investment Offerings
Crypto Wealth Manager Vaneck Launches Polygon and Avalanche Investment Offerings The wealth manager Vaneck has announced it has expanded its exchange-traded note (ETN) offerings to
What are memecoins good for? Social signaling, says Avalanche founder
Gareth Jenkinson11 hours agoWhat are memecoins good for? Social signaling, says Avalanche founderEmin Gün Sirer believes memecoins have become an entertaining entry point for crypto-curious newcomers but remain risky in
Minereum World Metaverse Is Planned to Be Launched in Q1 2022, Land Pre-Sale Is Live
Minereum World Metaverse Is Planned to Be Launched in Q1 2022, Land Pre-Sale Is Live sponsored Minereum, the project behind the first self-mining smart contract, welcomes you to The
Martin Young3 hours agoMultichain’s ‘mysterious withdrawals’ have whiffs of a ‘rug pull’ — ChainalysisChainalysis told Cointelegraph that it was “describing it as a possible rug pull” based on an analysis
Vittoria Benzine9 hours agoNew York MoMA now has tokenized artworks in its permanent collectionThe museum’s acquisition of two NFTs marked its first on-chain and AI holdings.1303 Total views8 Total sharesListen to arti
Finder Survey: Nigeria’s 24.2% Adoption Rating Is the Highest Rate of Crypto Ownership Globally
Finder Survey: Nigeria"s 24.2% Adoption Rating Is the Highest Rate of Crypto Ownership Globally According to the latest Finder Cryptocurrency Adoption Index, in October 2021, Niger
MicroStrategy Q1 net loss hits $53.1M but Bitcoin buying spree continues
Brayden Lindrea7 minutes agoMicroStrategy Q1 net loss hits $53.1M but Bitcoin buying spree continuesMicroStrategy has yet to adopt the new accounting standard that would have taken the billions of dollars in paper gains
Rakesh Upadhyay4 hours agoPrice analysis 8/25: BTC, ETH, BNB, XRP, ADA, SOL, DOGE, DOT, MATIC, TONBitcoin and altcoins lose more ground after comments from the Federal Reserve suggest that the regime of interest rate hik
Tristan Greene5 hours agoMeta launches community-licensed AI coding tool to the publicCode Llama is available for both personal and business use under the Llama2 community license agreement.806 Total views3 Total sharesL