Fun

Crypto community backs Tornado Cash devs with $2.3M legal fund

News Feed - 2024-06-20 12:06:00

Prashant Jha8 hours agoCrypto community backs Tornado Cash devs with $2.3M legal fundTornado Cash’s founders and developers are in the legal crosshairs, but the crypto community argues merely writing code shouldn’t be a crime.2305 Total views18 Total sharesListen to article 0:00Follow upOwn this piece of crypto historyCollect this article as NFTJoin us on social networksThe crypto community has rallied behind the developers of former crypto mixing service Tornado Cash, who have been charged with money laundering, sanctions violations and operating an unlicensed money-transmitting business — with one already having been convicted and sentenced to jail.


Following the arrests of Tornado Cash co-founder Roman Storm and developer Alexey Pertsev, the crypto community came together to establish JusticeDAO, an advocacy group that aims to raise money for the arrested individuals’ legal defense.


The group has raised over 654 Ether (ETH), worth $2.3 million at publishing time, through a fundraiser called “Free Alexey & Roman” on the decentralized platform Juicebox. The fund also raised 70 ETH via the JusticeDAO page.Alexey Pertsev and Roman Storm legal defense fund. Source:Juicebox


Juicebox releaseda publicly available spreadsheet tracking the expenses of the Free Alexey & Roman fund. According to the data, the fund spent $1.39 million in legal fees between December 2023 and May 2024. The fund expects to spend another $2.8 million in the next five months and an additional $400,000 in expert research and additional legal fees, with the total fees for 2024 anticipated to reach nearly $3.35 million in 2024.


The fund includes significant contributions from Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin, himself a privacy advocate who has published numerous papers and suggestions on enhancing privacy on Ethereum.


Advocates within the crypto community claim that creating the means to protect financial privacy — e.g., through a crypto mixer — is not a crime. However, regulators disagree.


Despite the help from the crypto community, the founders of Tornado Cash face serious charges.Tornado Cash founder appeals to dismiss


In 2022, The United States Treasury Department allegedthat notorious criminals used Tornado Cash to launder more than $7 billion in crypto assets for nearly three years.


Ayear later, in August 2023, the platform’s co-founders, Storm and Roman Semenov, were accused of money laundering and sanctions violations. Storm was arrested by the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation that same month, while Semenov was put on the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control sanction list.


Storm is facing three charges: conspiracy to commit money laundering, conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money-transmitting business and conspiracy to violate the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. He has pleaded not guilty to all the charges.


Recent: Crypto clicker games need real token use cases to be sustainable


Storm’s legal counsel appealed to dismiss the money laundering charges, arguing that they are “fatally flawed” and must be dismissed, given that Storm can’t control or prevent sanctioned entities from using the crypto mixer.


Storm’s lawyers argued that Tornado Cash was developed and publicly available before sanctioned hackers had the opportunity to use it.


In May 2024, a Dutch court found Tornado Cash developer Pertsev guilty of money laundering and sentenced him to five years and four months in prison for allegedly laundering $1.2 billion worth of illicit assets on the platform.Developers should be wary about end-use


The case has raised questions about how coders are held legally responsible for the end-use of the tools they create.


Josh Garcia, a partner at Ketsal — a law firm focused on fintech, Web3 and consumer financial services — believes that while it is wise to make developers think about the consequences of their code, it is burdensome for a small group of developers to chart out all foreseeable criminal uses of their software.


Gracia told Cointelegraph that the Dutch court’s decision would force developers in the Netherlands to stay anonymous or pseudonymous rather than risk criminal liability for building software.


“Some developers may even quit entirely out of fear the U.S. will take the same approach. For developers who are doxed and want to continue development efforts, the Dutch approach might force them to go underground,” he added.


Garcia believes the consequences of the Dutch approach may extend beyond blockchain. He questioned whether the CEO of a 3D printer manufacturer should worry about criminal liability if one of its users prints a firearm in a jurisdiction where guns are prohibited.


“If the Dutch sentiment carries over to the U.S., and free speech advocates cannot argue code is protected speech under our First Amendment, many developers will go underground, not just in blockchain but in any field with a potential threat of criminal liability. This will be a massive step backward for the blockchain community at large,” he said.


Rebecca Liao, co-founder and CEO of Web3 developer platform Saga and a Harvard Law School graduate, believes the case isn’t merely about writing code.


She told Cointelegraph that the U.S. legal system requires more than just the “act of writing code” to constitute a criminal offense — it necessitates that individuals demonstrate criminal intent.


Recent: TXSE ‘upstart’ stock exchange could become a crypto-friendly challenger


“In the case of Tornado Cash, the prosecution aimed to prove that the developers knowingly facilitated illegal activities, and the court ultimately agreed with this argument. These court actions indicate, in general, that developers must be vigilant about the potential misuse of their creations and implement safeguards to prevent legal repercussions, and the organizations they work for have to put processes in place to support them,” she explained.


Storm’s upcoming trial will be a pivotal case for the crypto industry, especially for privacy-focused services. The Dutch court’s prosecution of Pertsev has already sent ripples through the crypto developer community, and legal experts predict it will put unprecedented pressure on developers who work on similar projects in the near future.


Jamie Wright, founder of the Wright Law Firm, told Cointelegraph that historically, cases involving tech and criminal intent often result in severe penalties because of the “perceived threat these technologies pose to financial and regulatory systems.” He noted that in the case of Tornado Cash, the future will largely hinge on whether the courts see the actions as “neutral technological advancement or as knowingly enabling illegal activities.”# Law# Privacy# Court# Regulation# Tornado CashAdd reaction

News Feed

Gareth Jenkinson11 hours agoAnimoca still bullish on blockchain games, awaits license for metaverse fundAnimoca Brands co-founder Yat Siu expects a number of its blockchain gaming investments to come to market by the end
Bitcoin to Rise to $20K This Year Spurred by Government Money Printing and Covid-19: Bloomberg
Bitcoin to Rise to $20K This Year Spurred by Government Money Printing and Covid-19: BloombergBloomberg has forecast bitcoin to reach its record high of $20,000, and possibly $28,00
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC, ETH Fall to 1-Week Lows, as Markets Prepare for Big Week of Data
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC, ETH Fall to 1-Week Lows, as Markets Prepare for Big Week of Data Bitcoin was trading near a key support point on Monday as markets prepar
Helen Partz10 hours agoTether credits USDT growth surge to ETF excitement, emerging marketsTether’s USDT added at least $20 billion to its market capitalization in 2023, while rival stablecoin USDC lost the same amount
Ethereum Foundation website changes hint at investigation by ‘state authority’
Derek Andersen7 hours agoEthereum Foundation website changes hint at investigation by ‘state authority’The change occurred on Feb. 26, though no further information was provided, according to the foundation’s GitHu
Arijit Sarkar10 hours agoYield Protocol to permanently ‘wind down’ operations by December 2023Unfavorable crypto regulations in the United States, Europe and the United Kingdom was one of the factors for Yield Protoc
‘Ripple is well-positioned to pay a significant civil penalty,‘ says SEC
Turner Wright3 hours ago‘Ripple is well-positioned to pay a significant civil penalty,‘ says SECThe SEC’s filing on a proposed $1.95 billion in fines and penalties for Ripple suggested the firm needed an incentive
Turner Wright2 hours agoSam Bankman-Fried will get one day in court to meet with lawyersAccording to a judge"s order, SBF will be allowed access to one laptop and "WiFi device” for roughly 6.5 hours while meeting
Dogecoin Poised For A Huge Breakout: Here’s Why Today Could Be The Day
Este artículo también está disponible en español. The Dogecoin (DOGE) price stands at a critical juncture as technical analysts point toward a potentially significant bre
Study: 10% Growth in Crypto Market Cap Reduces Value of African Firms by 0.76%
Study: 10% Growth in Crypto Market Cap Reduces Value of African Firms by 0.76% A study undertaken by two assistant professors at American University in Cairo (AUC) has suggested th
UwU Lend faces second hack during $20M reimbursement process
Prashant Jha9 minutes agoUwU Lend faces second hack during $20M reimbursement processUwU exploiter strikes again and steals $3.5 million from the lend protocol as they begin the reimbursement process.52 Total viewsListen
BONK Meme Coin Sees Wild Price Fluctuations and Massive Holder Concentration
BONK Meme Coin Sees Wild Price Fluctuations and Massive Holder Concentration After the all-time cryptocurrency price highs in 2021, suffering through the Luna implosion of 2022 and