Fun

SEC drops Ethereum investigation to avoid ‘embarrassing’ court case

News Feed - 2024-06-20 11:06:00

Daniel Ramirez-Escudero36 minutes agoSEC drops Ethereum investigation to avoid ‘embarrassing’ court caseGary Gensler’s SEC has halted its investigation into whether Ether is a security. What could have motivated the SEC withdrawal, and is the fight over?389 Total viewsListen to article 0:00Follow upOwn this piece of crypto historyCollect this article as NFTJoin us on social networksThe United States Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) case to prove Ether is a security may not have been as strong as it let on.


On June 19, 2024, the SEC surprised the crypto industry when it officiallyclosed its investigation into whether Ether (ETH) is a security.


Consensys lawyer Laura Brookover said there will be “no more protestations from the SEC that Ether is a security.”


Brookover claimed that the SEC didn’t willingly decide todrop the investigation.


She said it was a reaction to being pushed to “lift the subpoenas on Consensys given their recent ETH [exchange-traded fund] rule change approvals predicated on ETH being a commodity.”Consensys letter to the SEC. Source: Consensys 


The letter from Consensys states that the SEC’s approval of spot Ether exchange-traded funds (ETFs) indicated that it had “updated its position to classify ETH as a commodity and not a security.” 


The SEC has not publicly confirmed Consensys’ thesis.ETF is no guarantee that Ether is a commodity


Carol Goforth, a professor at the University of Arkansas School of Law who specializes in business associations and securities regulation, told Cointelegraph that the SEC’s approval of a spot Ether ETF does not mean ETH is a commodity.


Goforth said that the “approval of an ETF has nothing to do with whether the underlying asset is a security.”


She added that there are already ETFs with commodities as the underlying asset:“Approval of an ETF has nothing to do with the appropriate classification of the underlying assets in which the fund invests.”


If the spot Ether ETF approval doesn’t necessarily force the SEC to demonstrate that ETH is a security, why did the SEC halt its investigation?Why did the SEC drop the investigation into Ethereum?


Goforth believes the SEC’s retreat is a “pretty good indication that the agency does not believe it can convince a court that ETH is a security.”


She suspects the SEC “concluded that it would be difficult to prove that ETH is a security under theHowey investment contract test because of how widely the asset is held and traded, and how much market forces dictate profitability.” She said that the SEC may have wanted to avoid a discomfiting defeat:“Previous statements made by SEC officials about the likely classification of Ether might have been embarrassing to an agency that claims classification is ‘clear.’”


In 2018, former SEC director William Hinmanstated that Ethereum was not a security.


In hisspeech, he mentioned that decentralization plays a key role in this determination. The network and its operations were sufficiently decentralized, meaning investors no longer expected a single entity to perform significant administrative efforts​.


Recent: Crypto clicker games need real token use cases to be sustainable


The speech suggested that Ethereum’s status as a non-security was clear, contrasting with the SEC’s ongoing scrutiny under Gensler.


The crypto industry’s main complaint is that theSEC has not consistently provided guidance on how the Howey test applies to Ethereum or other similar cryptocurrencies.The battle for U.S. crypto regulation is far from over


The crypto community may be happy that the SEC dropped its investigation.


Goforth said that it’s a “really positive development for the Ethereum network that the SEC is not currently trying to asses that ETH is a security.”


However, she said that the letter from the SEC only states that “at this time,” the SEC will not be continuing its investigation and that “this is not a final determination.”


Goforth believes “it is too early to say the industry is ‘winning’ given the lingering uncertainties over the appropriate classification of most crypto assets.”


Consensyshighlighted that despite this “momentous” victory, it’s not a “cure-all for the many blockchain developers, technology providers, and industry participants who have suffered under SEC’s unlawful and aggressive crypto enforcement regime.”Source: Joseph Lubin


Goforth claimed that the industry needs a “clear regulatory framework with which it is reasonably possible to comply” where purchasers can access accurate information, and industry participants can be held accountable for illicit activities.Source: Consensys


Consensys may have won the battle, but the war continues. The SEC is also scrutinizing staking, a core element of the Ethereum ecosystem.


American crypto exchange Kraken has already settled with the SEC for $30 million. The exchange stopped offering staking services after the commission alleged that its staking-as-a-service offering constituted a security.


Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong has even said that the exchange will take the SEC to court over staking if necessary.


Recent: TXSE ‘upstart’ stock exchange could become a crypto-friendly challenger


Goforth said that staking is “definitely a more complex” topic where “the SEC has alleged that staking itself involves an investment contract.”


She remarked that the SEC’s “position can be taken regardless of whether the underlying crypto asset is itself a security.”


The ongoing struggle for a clear regulatory framework in the U.S. crypto industry continues to be challenging.


However, recent developments might offer Ethereum advocates a momentary respite from some of the uncertainties surrounding Ether’s classification, offering a glimmer of hope in an otherwise tumultuous regulatory landscape.# Government# Security# Ethereum# SEC# US Government# United States# Regulation# Ethereum ETF# ETFAdd reaction

News Feed

Ex-Alameda Research co-CEO calls for ‘fair’ sentencing of Ryan Salame
Turner Wright7 hours agoEx-Alameda Research co-CEO calls for ‘fair’ sentencing of Ryan SalameSam Trabucco, who resigned as co-CEO of Alameda Research in August 2022, has largely remained absent from the public eye si
White Paper Published by Microsoft Describes an Ethereum-Based Tool to Combat Pirated Content
White Paper Published by Microsoft Describes an Ethereum-Based Tool to Combat Pirated Content Researchers from Microsoft, Alibaba Group, and Carnegie Mellon Univ
President Biden Insists US Recession Is Not Inevitable — Treasury Secretary Yellen Concurs
President Biden Insists US Recession Is Not Inevitable — Treasury Secretary Yellen Concurs President Joe Biden and Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen say that a U.S. recession is no
Cashing Out Bitcoin Using ATMs: Popular Youtuber Successfully Turns $16K in BTC Into Cash
Cashing Out Bitcoin Using ATMs: Popular Youtuber Successfully Turns $16K in BTC Into Cash On January 23, 2021, the popular Youtuber Mambafx published a video of
Tristan Greene17 hours agoCrypto investment products see largest weekly inflow since July 2022CoinShares’ latest weekly inflow report shows a substantial increase in investor appetite for digital asset investment produ
bitFlyer acquires FTX Japan, plans to launch crypto ETFs
Zoltan Vardai11 hours agobitFlyer acquires FTX Japan, plans to launch crypto ETFsThe acquisition could be another step toward the first spot crypto ETF launching in Japanese markets.1090 Total views2 Total sharesListen t
Genesis Digital Assets Reveals $431 Million Capital Raise — Mining Firm Aims for 1.4 Gigawatts by 2023
Genesis Digital Assets Reveals $431 Million Capital Raise — Mining Firm Aims for 1.4 Gigawatts by 2023 On Tuesday, the bitcoin mining firm Genesis Digital Assets announced the fi
Cryptocurrency Markets Moved by Regulatory Actions, Federal Reserve Bank Paper Shows
Cryptocurrency Markets Moved by Regulatory Actions, Federal Reserve Bank Paper Shows The Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas has published a paper showing how cryptocurrency markets are
ETC Group Releases Bitcoin Cash Report Praising High Usage and Vibrant Development
ETC Group Releases Bitcoin Cash Report Praising High Usage and Vibrant Development ETC Group, an ETF issuer company, released a report last month about the evolution of Bitcoin Cas
Tom Mitchelhill2 hours agoOptimism to sell $160M in OP tokens to 7 purchasers via private saleThe Optimism network has revealed that it will sell 116 million OP tokens in a series of planned sales.1278 Total views16 Tota
$250 Trillion in Assets Looking for Ideal Store of Value: A Bull Case for Bitcoin
$250 Trillion in Assets Looking for Ideal Store of Value: A Bull Case for Bitcoin The CEO of Nasdaq-listed billion-dollar company Microstrategy has made a strong
Quik․com Releases Update for Its NFT Domains – Web3 Domains Are Now Minting
Quik․com Releases Update for Its NFT Domains - Web3 Domains Are Now Minting sponsored The much-anticipatedmajor update to Quik.comhas now been made available to users, bringing th