Fun

4th Amendment Does Not Protect Bitcoin Data, US Fifth Circuit Court Rules

News Feed - 2020-07-05 10:07:32

4th Amendment Does Not Protect Bitcoin Data, US Fifth Circuit Court Rules


A Fifth Circuit panel of judges recently ruled that Fourth Amendment rights do not apply to cryptocurrency transaction data that stems from an exchange. The U.S. court ruled against the defendant, Richard Gratkowski, who attempted to leverage the Fourth Amendment in an appeal.


According to the ruling of a three-judge panel from the Fifth Circuit courts, the American government’s Fourth Amendment does not apply to bitcoin transactions used in a crime if they stem from virtual currency exchanges. Richard Gratkowski was charged with allegedly making payments to a child pornography website, and sent bitcoin (BTC) to the web portal via his Coinbase account.


Now the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) searched Gratkowski and found illicit materials at his home and they subpoenaed Coinbase for transaction records. However, Gratkowski appealed the case and said that his bitcoin transaction history deserves to be protected by the Fourth Amendment.


Specifically, Gratkowski leveraged the 2018 Supreme Court ruling from Carpenter v. the United States. That particular case deemed cellphone data was personal and protected by Fourth Amendment protections.


However, Judge Catharina Haynes used an old Supreme Court decision from 1939 called the United States v. Miller. That particular ruling said that bank records are not protected by the Fourth Amendment. Judge Haynes ruled:Coinbase is a financial institution, a virtual currency exchange, that provides Bitcoin users with a method for transferring bitcoin. The main difference between Coinbase and traditional banks, which were at issue in Miller, is that Coinbase deals with virtual currency while traditional banks deal with physical currency.


The other two judges agreed with Haynes, and the court noted that unlike cellphone data, bitcoin transactions are not “an intimate window into a person’s life.” The panel also highlighted that cryptocurrency transaction data was not a “pervasive or insistent part of daily life.” Of course, even though the case is controversial, bitcoiners are unsure of how the case will affect other U.S. lawsuits going forward.


Traditionally in America, decisions that are tied to the Supreme Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals, typically become formalized standards or law. Other judges will leverage the decision made during Gratkowski’s appeal process.


Founded in 1891, the Fifth Circuit is one of 13 American courts of appeals, and the branch is a federal court with appellate jurisdiction. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals presides over Texas, Mississippi, and Louisiana.


Now if other U.S. judges make contradictory rulings then this particular decision could be appealed again someday, and the weight of the three-judge panel decision may be tested. For now, and from the Fifth Circuit’s perspective, bitcoin data stemming from a virtual exchange like Coinbase is not protected by the Fourth Amendment.


Going forward, bitcoiners will simply have to wait for more court rulings that are similar to see if this decision holds water for an extended duration of time.


What do you think about the Fifth Circuit decision in the Gratkowski appeal? Let us know what you think about this subject in the comments section below.Cryptocurrency-Focused Docuseries Airs to Millions of Viewers via the Discovery Science ChannelNEWS | 2 hours agoBitcoin-Friendly Kanye West Running for US President 2020, Taking on Donald Trump and Joe BidenNEWS | 8 hours agoTags in this story4th Amendment, Bitcoin, Bitcoin (BTC), Bitcoin Data, Bitcoin Transactions, BTC, Coinbase, court of appeals, FBI, Fourth Amendment, Judge Catharina Haynes, louisiana, Mississippi, Supreme Court, Texas, US Court, virtual currency exchange


Image Credits: Shutterstock, Pixabay, Wiki CommonsPurchase Bitcoin without visiting a cryptocurrency exchange. Buy BTC and BCH here.Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. It is not a direct offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or a recommendation or endorsement of any products, services, or companies. Bitcoin.com does not provide investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice. Neither the company nor the author is responsible, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any content, goods or services mentioned in this article.Read disclaimer Show comments

News Feed

TRUMP token whale sells for $3.7M profit as memecoin starts decline
Zoltan Vardai14 hours agoTRUMP token whale sells for $3.7M profit as memecoin starts declineThe memecoin whale made an over 1,428% return on their initial investment in the TRUMP token.3538 Total views25 Total sharesList
Binance to Open Two Offices in Brazil, Company Hints at Debit Card Launch
Binance to Open Two Offices in Brazil, Company Hints at Debit Card Launch Binance, one of the biggest crypto exchanges by volume traded, has announced its expansion plans for Brazi
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Falls to $20,000 Range, as Sell-Off Extends
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Falls to $20,000 Range, as Sell-Off Extends Bitcoin declined for an eighth consecutive session on Tuesday, as the crash in crypto markets
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Rebounds on Friday, Following a Drop Below $19,000
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Rebounds on Friday, Following a Drop Below $19,000 Following a move below $19,000 on Thursday, BTC was able to rise above $20,000 during t
David Attlee14 hours agoNigeria’s SEC warns against trading on BinanceThe agency insists that the platform doesn’t have a license to work in the country and that its operation is illegal.4372 Total views32 Total shar
Judge finds Ripple Labs liable for $125M penalty in SEC case
Turner Wright3 hours agoJudge finds Ripple Labs liable for $125M penalty in SEC caseRipple’s civil case with the SEC has been ongoing since December 2020, when the regulator alleged the blockchain firm used XRP as an u
Cardano Could Drop To $0.54 If This Support Gives Out, Analyst Says
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu
Former Nintendo President States Gaming Companies Are Marching to the Metaverse
Former Nintendo President States Gaming Companies Are Marching to the Metaverse Former Nintendo of America President, Reggie Fils-Aimé, believes that the gaming industry is st
Report: $4B in Bitcoin Mining Loans Are in Distress — JPMorgan Analyst Says Price Pressure Stems From Miner Sales
Report: $4B in Bitcoin Mining Loans Are in Distress — JPMorgan Analyst Says Price Pressure Stems From Miner Sales Cryptocurrency-related lending has become a black smudge for the
Kim Dotcom Says ‘US Is Beyond Bankrupt,’ Digital Entrepreneur Predicts a ‘Controlled Demolition of Global Markets’
Kim Dotcom Says "US Is Beyond Bankrupt," Digital Entrepreneur Predicts a "Controlled Demolition of Global Markets" On June 5, 2022, the entrepreneur and activist known as Kim Dotco
Savannah Fortis9 hours agoCrypto community tells Elon Musk to dump Satoshi ‘X’ accountThe crypto community has asked Elon Musk to remove the X account under the name of Satoshi Nakamoto, claiming it is in breach of t
Coinbase Confirms ‘No Financing Exposure’ to Bankrupt Crypto Firms Celsius, Voyager, Three Arrows Capital
Coinbase Confirms "No Financing Exposure" to Bankrupt Crypto Firms Celsius, Voyager, Three Arrows Capital Crypto exchange Coinbase has confirmed that the company “had no fin