Fun

Ethereum gas fees: Too low or too high? No one can decide

News Feed - 2024-08-15 09:08:06

Omid Malekan8 hours agoEthereum gas fees: Too low or too high? No one can decideCritics who have a problem with volatile gas prices — on Ethereum or elsewhere — have the wrong vision for the future of crypto.717 Total views18 Total sharesListen to article 0:00OpinionOwn this piece of crypto historyCollect this article as NFTCOINTELEGRAPH IN YOUR SOCIAL FEEDFollow ourSubscribe onMuch of the historical debate around Ethereum has been around whether its gas fees are too high. This year, its fees have become exceedingly low, in part thanks to rollups — except during the Aug. 4-5 crash, when they were disproportionately elevated. So which is it?


The surprising answer is that everything worked as intended. Periodic spikes are how you’d expect a wholesale market to behave during peak demand. Those who point to these developments as problematic have the wrong vision for the future of crypto.


Backing up, the modular scaling philosophy is based on the idea that blockchain’s aren’t networks that process activity, they are the purveyors of a scarce asset called secure block space. Like any other scarce asset (such as land, oil or electricity), secure block space is continuously auctioned off to the highest bidder, and the winner is whoever needs it most. This will likely be either a whale or a wholesale buyer, such as a layer 2.


Related: Forget about Ethereum ETFs — Here"s what you can do instead


Monolithic chains have more of a network philosophy: they want to serve everyone on an equal footing. This is untenable because blockchains aren’t just networks in the way the internet is a network. If a video stream or email are delayed then it’s not that big of a deal. But if an important financial transaction is delayed, it could be catastrophic. Blockchains are predictable and secure transfer and settlement layers. In every other context where such a service is provided, both the service and the cost are tiered.Some users complained about gas fees during market volatility between Aug. 4-5. Source: X


Imagine if the post office charged the same for a second-class post card as it did an overnight package — it couldn’t possibly work because everyone would opt for the latter, even for non-priority parcels. Pricing supply to always be below demand means you have to constantly add capacity to prevent fees from climbing ever higher.Fees on Ethereum have been low in 2024 compared to past years. Source: X


But on a modular chain it doesn’t matter as much. Individual users still trading on L1 are there because they want max security. That only makes sense if they are doing large transactions. A trading firm doing a $5 million swap doesn’t care if gas goes to 500 gwei. It barely impacts their bottom line.


The other players on such an L1 are wholesale providers like rollups. These players also don’t care as much about short term spikes in base layer fees. They have a healthy profit margin when activity is normal and fees are low. This creates a cushion for them to operate at a loss during spikes. Ethereum gas fees between Aug. 7-14. Source: Etherscan


This is how every other market for scarce assets works. Airlines and gas stations are wholesale buyers of oil products. When oil prices are low, they have a bigger profit margin. When oil prices spike, they absorb most of it, possibly operating at a loss. If high prices persist, then they slowly raise their own. The important thing is that retail customers (flight passengers, car drivers, etc.) are one layer removed.


Related: Expect Bitcoin ETF options to launch before 2025


The caveat to all of thisin crypto is that, during the Aug. 4-5 crash, rollup gas fees also spiked. If my theory held true, that would not have happened. But that’s because the rollup fee market is very immature. In time, competition will force L2s to compete on price. Not just on the absolute level, but also in volatility. Some will even advertise themselves on this promise. When that happens, sequencers will squirrel away some of their profits during the good times to absorb shocks during the bad.


I’m confident that most gas fees will eventually be abstracted away from end-users, particularly retail ones. We already see this for some things like USD Coin (USDC) transactions on Base. Part of the appeal of launching your own L2 is the ability to treat gas costs/sequencing as a loss leader. The same will happen with dApps. (An example is UniswapX eating a portion of gas fees due to MEV) and even wallet providers. This UX development could still happen on a monolithic chain, but is more stable on a modular one.Omid Malekan is a guest columnist for Cointelegraph, an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School and the author of Re-Architecting Trust: The Curse of History and the Crypto Cure for Money, Markets, and Platforms.


This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal or investment advice. The views, thoughts, and opinions expressed here are the author’s alone and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions of Cointelegraph.# Cryptocurrencies# Ethereum# Analysis# Technology# Fees# Chain# Tech Analysis# OpinionAdd reaction

News Feed

US Senator Wants Congress to Step in With Crypto Guidance — Urges SEC to Provide Much More Clarity on Regulations
US Senator Wants Congress to Step in With Crypto Guidance — Urges SEC to Provide Much More Clarity on Regulations U.S. Senator Pat Toomey says Congress should step in and provide
Tristan Greene3 hours agoAI21 Labs debuts anti-hallucination feature for GPT chatbotsContextual Answers is designed for enterprise but could have far-reaching implications for the generative AI sector.1219 Total views6 T
Survey Finds Many Finance Managers Are Not Planning to Hold BTC— Volatility Cited as Key Concern
Survey Finds Many Finance Managers Are Not Planning to Hold BTC— Volatility Cited as Key Concern A new poll of finance managers by Gartner Finance finds that a
Airdrop success propels Bitget wallet to second most popular in Japan
Zoltan Vardai12 hours agoAirdrop success propels Bitget wallet to second most popular in JapanWeb3 wallet usability remains a key hurdle for mass crypto adoption, according to Bitget Wallet’s chief operating officer.26
Islamic Organization in Indonesia Issues Fatwa Against Cryptocurrency
Islamic Organization in Indonesia Issues Fatwa Against Cryptocurrency A provincial branch of one the largest Islamic organizations in Indonesia has declared cryptocurrency “
29 Crypto Exchanges Survive New Regulation in South Korea, 37 Exchanges Must Shut Down
29 Crypto Exchanges Survive New Regulation in South Korea, 37 Exchanges Must Shut Down The deadline for crypto exchanges and service providers in South Korea to meet requirements t
Helen Partz14 hours agoKuCoin crypto exchange to introduce mandatory KYC in JulyKuCoin’s Know Your Customer checks will require new users to complete identity verification to access all services, while existing non-KYC
Savannah Fortis10 hours agoChamp Medici talks Web3 communities, NFTs, music and gamingEntrepreneur and the son of legendary rapper Snoop Dogg, Cordell Broadus (Champ Medici), explains what it takes to bring legacy artist
Arijit Sarkar1 hour agoTikTok launches text posts feature to rival Twitter and ThreadsJust 20 days after Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta launched Threads to rival Elon Musk’s X, TikTok joined the race by allowing users to cre
Derek Andersen2 hours agoGovernment objects to ‘unnecessary,’ ‘prejudicial’ SBF jury selection questionsThe U.S. attorney sees no reason for potential jurors to discuss effective altruism or ADHD, among other thi
David Attlee6 minutes agoHead of Portugal Central Bank deems crypto unsustainable, calls for global regulationMário Centeno praised the European Union’s first comprehensive crypto framework, MiCA, but insisted on furt
Trump’s Tariff Pause Could Push Bitcoin Price Above $100,000, Pundit Reveals Exit Point
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu