Fun

Crypto law firm loses appeal to force SEC’s hand on Ether classification

News Feed - 2024-08-23 02:08:30

Jesse Coghlan3 hours agoCrypto law firm loses appeal to force SEC’s hand on Ether classificationHodl Law sued the SEC in 2022, claiming it could face the regulator’s ire for using Ethereum and wanted a court to force it to decide if ETH is a security.1813 Total views3 Total sharesListen to article 0:00NewsOwn this piece of crypto historyCollect this article as NFTCOINTELEGRAPH IN YOUR SOCIAL FEEDFollow ourSubscribe onA United States appeals court has backed a California federal judge’s decision to throw out a crypto-focused law firm’s pre-emptive lawsuit against the US Securities and Exchange Commission in an attempt to force the regulator to clarify its classification of Ether.


Hodl Law’s November 2022 complaint against the regulator in a San Diego district court failed to show “a realistic danger” of it facing SEC enforcement action for breaking securities laws just because it used the Ethereum blockchain and Ether (ETH), a ninth circuit appeals court panel said on Aug. 22.


“Hodl Law’s complaint contains no allegations that the SEC has investigated, prosecuted, or threatened to investigate or prosecute the law firm’s use of Ether or Ethereum,” the three-judge panel wrote in an unpublished opinion.


The firm hoped the suit would force the SEC to clarify its position on if it considers ETH a security after it launched a slate of enforcement actions against crypto firms, implicating dozens of cryptocurrencies under securities laws. 


“If the SEC determines that transactions involving Ether or the Ethereum network violate the Securities Act, Hodl Law would already be in violation of the law because it currently engages in such transactions as part of its law practice,” the panel wrote.


The judges backed the California court’s July 2023 dismissal of the case, finding that Hodl Law failed to find proof that the SEC had engaged in “final agency action,” meaning the regulator had decided that ETH is a security.Highlighted excerpt of the panel’s opinion holding that the SEC has not alleged ETH is a security in any of its enforcement actions. Source: Pacer


The panel added the law firm hadn’t identified “any authority that requires the SEC to engage in specific rulemaking or respond to private parties’ requests for guidance” on ETH’s legal classification.


Hodl Law’s senior managing partner Fred Rispoli wrote in an Aug. 22 X post that the court’s decision was “disappointing but expected.”


Related:Compliance experts should help regulate crypto — Silk Road 2.0 founder


“All we wanted was for the court to give us a chance to argue [ETH] is not a federal security,” he said. Source:Fred Rispoli


The SEC has not determined whether ETH and assets on the Ethereum blockchain are securities despite approving spot ETH exchange-traded funds in July.


The ninth circuit panel said it’s possible the SEC “will never decide that Ether or Ethereum is a ‘security’ under the Securities Act.”


Rispoli hit back at the panel’s holding, saying, “This is not how the rule of law is supposed to operate in the United States of America.”


“We have some more avenues to attempt to force the SEC to provide an answer to us,” Rispoli said. “We are not giving up.”


Magazine:DeFi and Ethereum are the ‘new narrative’: Michaël van de Poppe, X Hall of Flame# Ethereum# SEC# Court# RegulationAdd reaction

News Feed

Arbitrum whales move $58M into exchanges after token unlock
Ezra Reguerra34 minutes agoArbitrum whales move $58M into exchanges after token unlockArbitrum unlocked 1.1 billion tokens, worth around $2.32 billion, for its team, advisers and investors on March 16.395 Total views1 To
Donald Trump floats making Elon Musk a Cabinet member
Turner Wright7 hours agoDonald Trump floats making Elon Musk a Cabinet memberAfter a public endorsement from the Tesla CEO and an X Spaces discussion, Donald Trump said he would consider placing Elon Musk in a Cabinet po
It’s Too Soon to Write Libra’s Crypto Obituary
To paraphrase Mark Twain, rumors of the nation-state’s demise are greatly exaggerated. The exits of Mastercard, Visa, Paypal and four other firms from the Libra consortium ca
Jay Clayton Leaves SEC: Crypto Industry Hopeful for Bitcoin ETF Approval
Jay Clayton Leaves SEC: Crypto Industry Hopeful for Bitcoin ETF ApprovalChairman Jay Clayton is geared to leave the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) after President Don
After Overseeing the Largest Monetary Expansion in US History Biden Renominates Powell to Lead the Fed
After Overseeing the Largest Monetary Expansion in US History Biden Renominates Powell to Lead the Fed U.S. president Joe Biden revealed his intent on Monday to re-nominate Jerome
Buy Bitcoin because ‘your wealth is melting’ away — Unchained report
Nancy Lubale8 hours agoBuy Bitcoin because ‘your wealth is melting’ away — Unchained reportResearch by Unchained suggests that Bitcoin is the best savings tool for investors due to its unique monetary properties.34
Casper Network halts operations following security breach
Amaka Nwaokocha13 hours agoCasper Network halts operations following security breachThis incident serves as a reminder of the ever-present need for vigilance and proactive measures in the rapidly evolving world of blockc
A New Super PAC Aims to Elect BTC Advocates and ‘Vote out Anti-Bitcoin Politicians Like Brad Sherman, Elizabeth Warren’
A New Super PAC Aims to Elect BTC Advocates and "Vote out Anti-Bitcoin Politicians Like Brad Sherman, Elizabeth Warren" On Friday, Grant McCarty, the director of policy and public
The Reported Number of Stolen BTC Drops by 92% as ‘Bitcoin Security Appears to Be Improving’
The Reported Number of Stolen BTC Drops by 92% as "Bitcoin Security Appears to Be Improving" The number of stolen bitcoins that were publicly reported in 2020 dr
Oldest US Bank BNY Mellon Sets Up Crypto Unit to Offer Bitcoin Services
Oldest US Bank BNY Mellon Sets Up Crypto Unit to Offer Bitcoin Services The Bank of New York Mellon, BNY Mellon, has set up a digital asset unit. The oldest bank
Binance Joins Association of Certified Sanctions Specialists
Binance Joins Association of Certified Sanctions Specialists Cryptocurrency exchange Binance has become a member of an organization providing training for sanctions compliance. Wit
US Senator Calls on SEC Chairman to Provide Regulatory Clarity on Cryptocurrencies
US Senator Calls on SEC Chairman to Provide Regulatory Clarity on Cryptocurrencies A U.S. senator has asked the chairman of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Gary