Fun

Ripple Files Motion for Court to Toss XRP Securities Lawsuit

News Feed - 2019-09-20 07:09:56

Ripple, the cryptocurrency firm behind the XRP token, has requested a federal court dismissal of a class-action lawsuit; all while ignoring one major issue, XRP"s security status.


The original lawsuit was first launched back in early 2018, by a handful of disgruntled XRP investors. The plaintiffs claimed that Ripple violated securities laws during the initial offering of the token; stating that XRP was intrinsic to Ripple"s operational integrity.


The relationship between XRP and Ripple has been a mostly grey area. This association has been put to the test in federal court for most of 2018, and now, well into 2019. Too Little Too Late


Today, Ripple filed the motion to dismiss, with the firm basing the dissolution of the lawsuit on the basis that the plaintiff, Bradley Sostack, delayed in filing the suit. The company states that Sostack should have voiced his concerns back in 2013 after the cryptocurrency"s initial coin offering (ICO); rather than 2018, when the lawsuit claims were brought forward. Ripple"s lawyers cite a three-year statute of repose, which under the securities act, limits liability claims to a three year period within which to file. This statute is highlighted within Ripple"s motion to dismiss : "Under Plaintiff’s own allegations, Defendants offered XRP to the public throughout 2013 through 2015. Accordingly, the three-year statute of repose expired as of 2016 (three years after the sales cited in the May 2015 settlement) and in no case later than May 2018 (three years after the May 2015 settlement agreement in which ‘Defendants acknowledged that they had sold XRP to the general public,’ Complaint ¶ 25). The Securities Act claims in the Complaint, filed August 5, 2019, are therefore untimely and barred by the statute of repose.”


The proposal also indicates Sostack"s jurisdiction in filing the claim, noting that it was listed under Califonia state law, not federal securities law, and therefore should be disregarded. Is XRP a Security?


Interestingly, despite citing securities law, Ripple has been keen to evade a crucial question of XRP"s security status. This is has been a significant point of contention both within the lawsuit itself, and the wider cryptocurrency community. As per the motion, the approach of Ripple"s lawyers on the issue was that it didn"t require addressing... “Because of the multiple, independent grounds for dismissing this action, the Court need not resolve whether XRP is a security or currency for purposes of this Motion, which assumes Plaintiff’s allegation that XRP is a security.”


This was of particular note to many today, as the question of XRP"s classification was once again raised. Crypto Twitter"s resident lawyer Jake Chervinsky was one of the first to highlight this point, stating: Ripple has finally filed their motion to dismiss in the pending securities class action regarding XRP. They make twelve separate arguments for dismissal of the plaintiff"s claims. Not a single one squarely addresses whether XRP is an unregistered security. Ripple"s Regulation Woes


The argument over XRP"s status has been drawn-out and lengthy. The SEC uses the Howey test to decide whether or not a digital asset should be classified as a security.


The Howey test, formulated in 1946 by the US Supreme Court, strives to determine asset classification. Per the test, a security is defined as an investment of money in a common enterprise, with an expectation of profits from said investment, from profits originating via the efforts of a third party promoter.


Ripple CEO Brad Galringhouse has long stood by his estimation that XRP doesn"t fit the criteria stated within the Howey test. Garlinghouse spoke on the lawsuit back in 2018, noting that XRP exists independently of Ripple, and therefore doesn"t classify as a security.



Will Thor"s Hammer Strike?


Last month Sostack reignited his original claims, by including SEC guidance which alluded to XRP"s security status. The filing read: “As explained in more detail below, applying the analysis in the SEC Framework and applicable precedent, the XRP tokens offered and sold by Defendants have all the traditional hallmarks of a security."


Bitcoin bull and XRP detractor, Tone Vays jumped into the fray. Citing Sostack"s amended complaint, suggesting that the SEC would bring down "Thor"s Hammer" on Ripple. Tone Vay"s suggests the SEC will bring down "Thor"s Hammer" on Ripple over XRP"s classification | Source: Tone Vays, Twitter


XRP"s classification is of fair importance to the cryptocurrency space, as it would stand as a precedent to other altcoins; therefore, the decision of the court as to throw the case may have wide-spanning ramifications. This article was edited by Samburaj Das. Last modified (UTC): September 20, 2019 11:33 AM

News Feed

SLP Token Market Cap Surpasses $50 Million
SLP Token Market Cap Surpasses $50 Million For over a year now, the Simple Ledger Protocol (SLP) token universe has grown quite vast. There are now more than 6,000 SLP tokens in
US Financial Services Committee Hearing Discussed the Creation of a ‘Digital Dollar’
US Financial Services Committee Hearing Discussed the Creation of a "Digital Dollar"On June 11, 2020, the United States Congress Financial Services Committee held a remote hearing a
Marc Andreessen, Galaxy Digital, Accolade, back new $75 million crypto fund: Report
Zoltan Vardai11 hours agoMarc Andreessen, Galaxy Digital, Accolade, back new $75 million crypto fund: ReportThe fund was announced during an uptick of institutional interest in crypto investments.4626 Total views7 Total
El Salvador’s Bitcoin treasury is now $85M in profit amid BTC rally
Martin Young5 hours agoEl Salvador’s Bitcoin treasury is now $85M in profit amid BTC rallyThe Central American nation’s Bitcoin stash is now worth more than $200 million, and recent government initiatives have been a
Polkadot (DOT) Breakout Looms With $17 Target In Sight – Details
Este artículo también está disponible en español. The Polkadot (DOT) market endured a rather turbulent trading week marked by significant losses. According to data from C
33,000 Companies in China Claim to Use Blockchain Technology
33,000 Companies in China Claim to Use Blockchain Technology China now has more than 33,000 registered companies claiming to use blockchain technology in their businesses, accord
An Unknown Individual Signed a Message Associated With BTC Block 1,018, Reward Was Minted 16 Days After Satoshi Launched Bitcoin
An Unknown Individual Signed a Message Associated With BTC Block 1,018, Reward Was Minted 16 Days After Satoshi Launched Bitcoin On Nov. 15, 2022, a post was created on the forum w
Ana Paula Pereira6 hours agoCosmos Hub upgrades to offer liquid stakingThe upgrade introduces a liquid staking module, eliminating a 21-day locking period applied for unstaked ATOM tokens.1005 Total views29 Total sharesL
Meta announces VR education metaverse for ages 13 and up
Tristan Greene7 hours agoMeta announces VR education metaverse for ages 13 and upThe University of Glasgow, Stanford University, and New Mexico State are already using Quest headsets to educate students.2906 Total views3
NYC Mayor Undeterred by Falling Bitcoin Price, Says Buying the Dip Could Yield ‘Good Profit’
NYC Mayor Undeterred by Falling Bitcoin Price, Says Buying the Dip Could Yield "Good Profit" The mayor of New York City, Eric Adams, is not deterred by bitcoin’s volatility,
Multilotto: Play Transparent Online Lotteries With Equal Opportunities for Every Player
Multilotto: Play Transparent Online Lotteries With Equal Opportunities for Every Player When you hear about gambling, you’ll remember some fancy Casino res
Crypto Exchanges Binance and Kuna Suspend Card Transactions in Ukrainian Hryvnia
Crypto Exchanges Binance and Kuna Suspend Card Transactions in Ukrainian Hryvnia Major cryptocurrency exchanges operating in Ukraine have temporarily suspended operations with hryv