Fun

The IRS Just Issued Its First Cryptocurrency Tax Guidance in 5 Years

News Feed - 2019-10-10 02:10:16

The U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has published its first guidance in five years for calculating taxes owed on cryptocurrency holdings.


Industry members have been eagerly awaiting the update since May 2019, when IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig said the agency was working on providing fresh guidance. The agency’s 2014 guidance left many questions unanswered, and the crypto market has grown more complex in the years since.


As expected, the guidance notice released Wednesday addresses: the tax liabilities created by cryptocurrency forks; the acceptable methods for valuing cryptocurrency received as income; and how to calculate taxable gains when selling cryptocurrencies.


Drew Hinkes, a lawyer with Carlton Fields and the general counsel to Athena Blockchain, told CoinDesk that “from the tax collector’s standpoint, this is the right answer,” though Certified Public Accountant Kirk Phillips said he was surprised that the guidance basically only addressed forks. Forks


Resolving a long-standing question, the guidance says new cryptocurrencies created from a fork of an existing blockchain should be treated as “an ordinary income equal to the fair market value of the new cryptocurrency when it is received.”


In other words, tax liabilities will apply when the new cryptocurrencies are recorded on a blockchain – if a taxpayer actually has control over the coins and can spend them.


The document reads: “If your cryptocurrency went through a hard fork, but you did not receive any new cryptocurrency, whether through an airdrop (a distribution of cryptocurrency to multiple taxpayers’ distributed ledger addresses) or some other kind of transfer, you don’t have taxable income.”


James Mastracchio, a partner at Eversheds Sutherland, told CoinDesk that this applies when there is a distinctly different cryptocurrency as a result of the hard fork.


The IRS language might create more confusion, said Jerry Brito, executive director at Coin Center.


“While the new guidance offers some much-needed clarity on certain questions related to calculating basis, gains, and losses, it seems confused about the nature of hard forks and airdrops,” Brito told CoinDesk, adding: “One unfortunate consequence of this guidance is that third parties can now create tax reporting obligations for you by simply forking a network whose coins you own, or foisting on you an unwanted airdrop.”


Individuals would be assessed income when they receive the asset, Hinkes said.


“Receipt is defined by ‘dominion and control’ … so it’s ability to transfer, sell, exchange or dispose of the asset according to this guidance,” he said. “The fear is that someone maliciously airdrops and tags you with a giant liability. But [this] fear is a bit oversold because you would only be liable for new income based on the fair market value of the asset when received, and most forks don’t start out with a high valuation.”


Phillips said it was possible that an individual with an ethereum wallet, for example, could receive an ERC-20 token from an airdrop without realizing it. Depending on how the token’s value fluctuates, this may result in them having to pay income tax on an asset that was worth more when they received it than when they sell the asset.


“This can happen when coins hit a high water mark of price discovery right after the airdrop event and the heavy selling could sink the price to a level from which is never recovers,” he said.


The issue has grown more salient in recent years, as fights over protocol changes caused rifts in various crypto communities, leading to splinter currencies like ethereum classic and bitcoin cash.


Holders of the original bitcoin and ethereum could automatically claim a like amount of the new coins, raising the question of whether and under what conditions they would owe taxes on the windfall.


Now crypto holders and their accountants have a roadmap. Cost basis


The new IRS document also offers long-awaited clarification on how taxpayers can determine the cost basis, or fair market value of coins received as income, such as from mining or the sale of goods and services.


Cost basis should be calculated by summing up all the money spent to acquire the crypto, “including fees, commissions and other acquisition costs in U.S. dollars.”


A third key issue addressed by the new IRS guidance is how to determine the cost basis of each unit of cryptocurrency that is disposed of in a taxable transaction (such as a sale).


This is an issue because someone might buy bitcoin in multiple transactions over a span of years; when they sold some of it, it was unclear which purchase price to use for calculating taxable gains.


The value of the crypto purchased on an exchange is determined by the amount the exchange sold it for in U.S. dollars. The income basis, in this case, will include commissions, fees and other costs of the purchase.


If the crypto is bought on a peer-to-peer exchange or a DEX, it is possible to use a crypto price index to determine the fair market value. In the words of IRS, this can be “a cryptocurrency or blockchain explorer that analyzes worldwide indices of a cryptocurrency and calculates the value of the cryptocurrency at an exact date and time.”


When selling crypto, taxpayers can identify the coins they are disposing of, “either by documenting the specific unit’s unique digital identifier such as a private key, public key, and address, or by records showing the transaction information for all units” in a single account or address, the IRS wrote.


This information, the document states, must show: “(1) the date and time each unit was acquired, (2) your basis and the fair market value of each unit at the time it was acquired, (3) the date and time each unit was sold, exchanged, or otherwise disposed of, and (4) the fair market value of each unit when sold, exchanged, or disposed of, and the amount of money or the value of property received for each unit.”


The new guidance allows for “first-in, first-out” accounting or specifically identifying when the cryptocurrencies being sold were acquired, Mastracchio said.


“Let’s say I bought my first unit at $5,000 and my second unit at $2,000 and then I sold one of my units. I can identify the unit or I can use ‘first-in, first-out,"” he said. “From a tax planning perspective, you may want to be specific about which unit you sold or you may want to use first-in, first-out because sometimes you want a capital gain and sometimes you might want a loss.” Other issues


In a disappointment to crypto users who like to spend their coins on everyday purchases like cups of coffee, the IRS specifically said it would not create an exemption for transactions below a certain threshold.


Paying somebody for service will result in a capital gain or loss, which should be calculated as “the difference between the fair market value of the services you received and your adjusted basis in the virtual currency exchanged.”


Purchases of goods and services were deemed taxable when the IRS issued its original guidance in 2014, which said that digital currencies were to be treated as property rather than currency for tax purposes. This discouraged casual spending and made tax season burdensome for users who wanted to diligently report their obligations.


Nikhilesh De contributed reporting.


IRS building image via Shutterstock

News Feed

Prashant Jha11 hours agoCME becomes second-largest Bitcoin futures exchange as open interest surgesThe surge in CME Bitcoin futures open interest has helped the regulated derivatives platform attain a 25% market share in
XRP Daily RSI Trendline Breaks Down – What It Means For Price
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu
Bitcoin Price Could Run Up To $131,000 — But It Must Hold Above This Level
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu
Australia Crypto Merchant Trade Sets $74K Monthly Record With BCH Capturing 97%
Australia Crypto Merchant Trade Sets $74K Monthly Record With BCH Capturing 97% Cryptocurrency payments in Australia, which have been growing in volume in the past few years, hav
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Consolidates, Following Turbulent Weekend of Trading
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Consolidates, Following Turbulent Weekend of Trading Recent declines in the world’s two largest cryptocurrencies eased to start the
Swiss SIX Exchange Lists Tezos ETP With Staking Rewards
New financial products are coming to tezos (XTZ), one of a handful major proof-of-stake (PoS) blockchains up and running today. On Thursday, crypto startup Amun AG launched the Amun
Meta loses bid to wriggle out of billionaire’s crypto scam ad lawsuit
Jesse Coghlan5 hours agoMeta loses bid to wriggle out of billionaire’s crypto scam ad lawsuitMeta cited a section of a 1996 federal law in an attempt to escape a crypto ad lawsuit from Australian billionaire Andrew For
Binance to Help South Korean City of Busan Grow Crypto Adoption, Develop Blockchain Ecosystem
Binance to Help South Korean City of Busan Grow Crypto Adoption, Develop Blockchain Ecosystem Binance is helping the South Korean city of Busan “grow crypto adoption within
Gareth Jenkinson1 minute agoHut8 relocates 6,400 rigs, sees growth in AI & high performance computingBitcoin mining firm Hut8 continues to relocate miners from idle North Bay site as demand for AI and high power comp
LBank Exchange Will List STEP on January 21, 2022
LBank Exchange Will List STEP on January 21, 2022 press release PRESS RELEASE. INTERNET CITY, DUBAI, Jan. 21, 2022 – LBank Exchange, a global digital asset trading platform,
GameFi Project ArchLoot Provides NFT User Builder for Creative Playability
GameFi Project ArchLoot Provides NFT User Builder for Creative Playability press release PRESS RELEASE.Singapore, May 3, 2022 –NFTs have disrupted the gaming industry with th
Value Locked in Decentralized Finance Slides 17% Lower Over the Last 30 Days
Value Locked in Decentralized Finance Slides 17% Lower Over the Last 30 Days The value locked in decentralized finance (defi) protocols has lost 17.77% over the last 30 days, falli