Fun

As Lightning’s Economy Takes Shape, Devs Are Split on Proposed Fee Hike

News Feed - 2019-10-21 10:10:08

Fees aren’t just a topic of discussion for bitcoin users anymore. As the tech matures and an economy develops, fee discussions are making their way into the lightning network too.


This past weekend, bitcoiners and lightning fanatics gathered in an industrial Berlin sector for the first-ever Lightning Conference. With topics ranging from onboarding and interface design to the vogue economics of the nascent payment layer, Lighting Conference attendees said the event had the feel of bitcoin’s early days.


However, lightning isn’t quite new. When it first debuted following its release of the white paper in 2015, three major teams sprung up among a sea of hobbyists: Eclair, c-Lightning, and Lightning Labs. Over the two-day conference, questions over wallet design and lightning apps were joined by concerns over the network’s next steps given its relative explosion over the past year.


One such question was default fees, the minimum price to send a payment through a lightning network channel.


Currently, default fee settings scrape the bottom of the barrel at 1 satoshi plus 1 parts per million (or 0.000001 percent) of the payment. In a word, insignificant. One satoshi (a one-hundred millionth of a bitcoin) is worth around $0.00008252 at press time.


Node operators have the option to raise the basic fee, yet historically the baseline hasn’t deviated much. Blockstream’s c-Lightning Rusty Russell pointed out that some two-thirds of nodes don’t charge over the default. To spur the development of a fee market, Russell called for an uptick in the default fee from 1 sats plus 1 ppm to 5 sats and 500 ppm in an Oct. 10 email to lightning developers.


In essence, his proposal would flip the fee market upside down: nodes would bid down for processing payments as opposed to bidding up. ‘Change is coming’


Some level of fee increase is generally seen as necessary in the lightning community. As lightning app (lapp) developers and others build on the layer 2 system, Russell told CoinDesk he has concerns for future developers working on the basis of the current setup.


“We measure chemicals in parts per million … somebody coming in new might go, ‘all right cool, we’re going to do one part per million,"” Russell said. They need a warning that it’s going to change, he added.


Russell’s proposal was seconded by Pierre-Marie Padiou, CEO and founder of ACINQ, the parent company of lightning company Eclair, in an email. Zap Solutions founder Jack Mallers also motioned support for the fee bump when asked by CoinDesk.


While the change would be small monetarily, other lightning developers believe a simple fee proposal could negatively affect the project’s decentralized image. The wrong notion?


As part of the bitcoin universe, lightning has co-opted bitcoin’s enthusiasm for individual sovereignty and free markets. Understanding Russel’s proposal within the context of the network, then, becomes political: would the big three lightning developers be setting a precedent by changing the default fee? And if so, what are the implications?


Lightning Labs CTO Olaoluwa Osuntokun came out strongly against the proposal which he believes could easily be taken out of context, saying “this post promotes the notion that somehow in Lightning, developers decide on fees,” in an Oct. 11  response to Russell’s proposal.


“The operators set the fees. If the fees are too high, they don’t get paid … that’s the market,” he said.


Osuntokun told CoinDesk that education initiatives matter more and developers should steer clear of topics rife for misrepresentation.


Lightning Labs’ CEO Elizabeth Stark agreed, telling CoinDesk that the fee market should develop from the ground up, not top-down.


“I don’t think developers should be changing these defaults,” Stark said. “I think the fee market will emerge – it’s going to have to professionalize.”


At the end of the day, it’s still early for the bitcoin payment solution. Mallers told CoinDesk the overhead for participating in the network remains low and, default fee increase or not, the network is heading in the right direction.


“The cost of getting on the network and routing is downloading free software on a laptop,” he concluded.


Olaoluwa Osuntokun image via William Foxley for CoinDesk

News Feed

Chainalysis will help Tether monitor secondary market for illicit activity
Derek Andersen3 hours agoChainalysis will help Tether monitor secondary market for illicit activityThe blockchain analytics firm will provide tools to spot sanctioned and illicit activity and provide market information.5
William Suberg15 hours agoFirst Bitcoin ETF trades $1.5B as GBTC ‘discount’ echoes $69K BTC priceProShares and Grayscale lead a surge of activity in Bitcoin investment products, with analysis confident of implied dem
Will Bitcoin Drop Even Lower? Here’s What Experts Predict
Este artículo también está disponible en español. Bitcoin is experiencing a severe downturn over the past few days. After trading above $96,000 on Monday, its price slipp
Investors flock to ETH products over BTC as markets recover: CoinShares
Martin Young5 hours agoInvestors flock to ETH products over BTC as markets recover: CoinSharesEthereum funds also lead Bitcoin ETPs on monthly performance with $150 million in inflows so far this month.1952 Total views33
Jesse Coghlan6 hours agoRipple gets formal approval for Singapore payments licenseRipple said it received its fully-fledged digital payment tokens license from the Monetary Authority of Singapore.2824 Total views14 Total
Venezuela blocks Binance, X amid presidential election dispute
Jesse Coghlan6 hours agoVenezuela blocks Binance, X amid presidential election disputeBinance has assured its users that their funds are safe after Venezuela cut off access to the exchange and social media platform X.328
Jesse Coghlan3 hours agoSam Bankman-Fried seeks expert to counter testimony from DOJ witnessesFormer FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried intends to call on a financial expert to rebuff testimonies from Caroline Ellison, Gary Wang,
Marcel Pechman10 hours ago3 reasons why Bitcoin price failed to break $37KBitcoin’s latest price pullback to $35,000 was driven by softer U.S. inflation, China’s economic challenges and regulatory uncertainties.4678
Snaky Way Presale Live: AI Meme Coin $AKE Gears Up for Bull Run
Reason to trust Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality Created by industry experts and meticulously reviewed The highest standards in reporting and pu
Crypto Exchange Zebpay Announces Relaunch in India Ahead of Supreme Court Decision on RBI Ban
Crypto Exchange Zebpay Announces Relaunch in India Ahead of Supreme Court Decision on RBI Ban Zebpay is returning to India more than a year after closing down local crypto exchan
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Heads Towards $40,000 Following FOMC
Bitcoin, Ethereum Technical Analysis: BTC Heads Towards $40,000 Following FOMC Bitcoin moved closer to $40,000 during Thursday’s session, as traders continued to react to ye
OpenAI partners with lab that created the atomic bomb, but for bioscience
Tom Mitchelhill2 hours agoOpenAI partners with lab that created the atomic bomb, but for bioscienceOpenAI is partnering with Los Alamos National Laboratory, which conducts research in fields including national security,